|

POSTED 10 AUGUST, 2009
The Two
Houses of Israel:
Biblical Passages That Deserve
Our Attention
by
J.K. McKee
editor@tnnonline.net
Since the mid-to-late 1990s, the Messianic movement has exploded in
number, particularly as many non-Jewish
Believers began to investigate their Hebraic
Roots, and were led into Messianic
congregations. In the case of my family, my late
father Kimball McKee had investigated the Jewish
Roots of Christianity via Zola Levitt in the
1980s, and brought a kind of educational
Passover to our United Methodist Church every
Holy Week during Easter. After his passing, and
as my mother remarried and our new blended
family had to look for a new kind of Christian
expression (largely independent from Wesleyan-Arminianism
and Reformed-Calvinism), we were led into
Messianic Judaism. My mother and stepfather went
on a tour to Israel in 1994, and within a year
we were attending a Messianic Jewish
congregation. Before too long, the Messianic
lifestyle, many of you have come to know and
embrace, was a steady part of who we were.
Like many new Messianic Believers, even though the Lord was leading
us into Messianic Judaism, we largely did not
understand why we felt so drawn to the Torah,
the Sabbath, the Biblical holidays, or even
kosher eating. Was it just because we were
convicted by God that these things were for
today, that Jesus did them, and that the New
Testament really did not do away with them? Or,
was the question that many non-Jews entering
into the Messianic movement ask—“Am I really
Jewish and not know it?”—a part of it? In the
late 1990s, an even more provocative question
started to be asked by non-Jews in the Messianic
movement: “Could I instead be a part of the
scattered tribes of Israel?”
Anyone who has tried to address what has often been labeled the
“Two-House teaching” since that time has caused
some degree of (significant) controversy. On one
side, it is one thing to ask whether
something more than meets the eye is going
on in the Messianic world, with so many non-Jews
being led to the Torah and to things of Judaism.
On the other hand, it is something else for
non-Jewish Believers to forcibly assert that
they are “returning Ephraim,” in fulfillment of
various Scriptures, singing songs praising
themselves about it, and being completely
insensitive to legitimate Jewish and Messianic
Jewish needs. And on top of all of this, it is
absolutely undeniable that the Two-House
sub-movement has been saturated with a great
deal of opportunism and merchandising (and in a
few cases, outright theological heresy), and has
not done as well as it should have in trying to
refine what this all actually is from the
Scriptures.
I think it is safe to say that with all of the non-Jewish Believers
entering into the Messianic movement today,
something more than meets the eye is going
on—and it is likely something more than just
people being convicted by the Lord that they
need to keep the Sabbath or the feasts.
Likewise, I think that if there is more going
on—the end-time restoration of Israel,
perhaps—that the enemy desperately wants it to
be discredited. He does not want people to
discuss it in a fair-minded and reasonable way,
and he wants those who bring up legitimate
questions about various verses of the Bible to
be silenced. And seeing some of the dynamics in
both Messianic Judaism and the Two-House
sub-movement at present in 2009, I really do
pray that one day reason will finally prevail
over rhetoric!
However, as the Lord may remind you, “Do
not let your heart be troubled, nor let it be
fearful” (John 14:27). If something really big
is going on today in the Messianic movement, or
at least has started, we have the duty as
responsible readers and interpreters of God’s
Word to investigate it. If we can make the
considerable effort to sort between the actual
data, and not the noisy racket, then we
might be able to get somewhere.
The Populist Two-House Teaching
Much of what has been promoted in the past decade, labeling itself
as “the Two-House teaching,” is not very
Biblical. There, I said it. I will even
give it a label: the populist Two-House
teaching. What this view actually advocates
is that if a non-Jewish person is led into the
Messianic movement, then it is an obvious
indication that he or she must be a scattered
Israelite coming home. This is a Two-House
teaching focused more on one’s physical pedigree
and people trying to find an identity than
anything else. This is the Two-House
sub-movement that is focused on human feelings
of being “born again again” by one thinking that
he or she is a part of physical Israel,
and/or on a pseudo-history of thinking that this
tribe or that tribe can be traced to this or
that nationality. The work of Yeshua in the
salvation process is less important than being
an Israelite. What makes it populist is that it
can be easily marketed. What also makes it
populist is that it feeds opportunism.[1]
I have shared this with very few people, but a number of years ago,
I was ready to completely throw away the
Two-House teaching. My first exposure to it back
in 1999 was a mild form of the populist
variety. I started writing with an emphasis on
“Ephraim and Judah.” After a number of years,
though, I had seen some of the teachings that
the populist Two-House view is commonly
associated with: a grossly unbalanced emphasis
on the Sacred Name, fierce anti-Christian
rhetoric, disparaging of the Greek Apostolic
Scriptures, conspiracy theories and
pseudo-history, and even fierce opposition to
mainline Jewish traditions and promotion of the Karaite calendar. (A few years later, a
particular Two-House proponent would actually
come out and publicly endorse polygamy.)
Certainly, if you believe in bringing Jewish Believers and
non-Jewish Believers together as the “one new
humanity” (Ephesians 2:15, NRSV/CJB) intended by
the work of Messiah Yeshua, and the spiritual
heritage we have inherited from Judaism—then
maybe I had been taken for a ride. I thought
what the Two-House sub-movement would also do
would be to honor the spiritual heritage we have
inherited from Christianity. Huge parts of the
Two-House sub-movement were doing anything
but this (and still do), and so I had
enough. They were not bringing people together
to encourage mutual honor and respect.
But there was always a significant problem with trying to totally
throw away the Two-House teaching. My major
problems were over the antics that had
become commonly associated with some of this
sub-movements so-called leaders—people who, in
the Apostle Paul’s words, “what
they were makes no difference to me; God shows
no partiality” (Galatians 2:6). Removing all of
the antics and nonsense that were associated
with these parts the Two-House sub-movement to
the side, forgetting some of the overstatements
that people had made, and putting opportunism
out of my head—I would still be left with one
thing in front of me: the Biblical text.
Common excuses made for people not considering,
or outright dismissing, this subject matter, are
usually things like the Sacred Name agenda, the
Karaite calendar, denigrating the Greek New
Testament, or even that women were involved in
initially asking some of the questions.[2]
Yet when you put all of these kind of reasons
for ignoring the Two-House issue off to the
side, you still have to sit down with an open
Bible and deal with it. Try to find whatever
excuses you may in avoiding the subject matter,
you have to provide honest interpretations for
yourself of passages like the two-stick prophecy
of Ezekiel 37:15-28, or the promise of the New
Covenant in Jeremiah 31:31-34. And when you
survey the Scriptures, you find that there are
many more passages you have to pay attention to.
Unless you simply choose to allegorize things,
it is quite difficult to argue from the Word
that all Israel has already been restored in its
fullness.
I simply found too many references in the Bible
to a Two-House teaching. This might not
be the populist Two-House teaching, but it is
something that has to be engaged with on some
level. It is a recognition that something more
is happening in today’s Messianic world than
just the salvation of Jewish people, and
non-Jewish Believers embracing their Hebraic
Roots—but whatever this is it has been largely
clouded because of fundamentalist opportunism.
We might not even have all of the answers we
want this side of Yeshua’s return, and some
things may go on without people knowing about
it. But, something important has started that
no human being can stop.
Toward a Biblical Two-House Teaching
I would submit that the populist Two-House teaching that has grown
in up in the 1990s and into the 2000s is
something that can be easily dismissed by many
people. I dismiss it myself. But this
does not mean that the subject matter as a whole
can be easily dismissed. While some Two-House
“leaders” and groups would prefer to spend their
time having another conference or weekend
seminar to make themselves feel better or even
superior to others, God’s Word impels us to do
things much differently. We have to recognize
that if there is a Biblical Two-House teaching
seen in the verses of Scripture, including
many unfulfilled prophecies, it is time that
we identify them and systematically begin to
examine them. If we can do this, then not
only can the attention be removed from a base
populism—which has not gained a great deal of
credibility in the wider world of Judaism and
Christianity—but we can refine our
understanding of what the whole “Two Houses
of Israel” thing really is. If all Israel really
is in the process of being restored, we have a
responsibility to understand what it is,
Biblically, and to know what the mission of such
an Israel is to be as God’s chosen community of
faithful.
It is not at all encouraging to see the common Messianic Jewish
attitude promoted today toward the Two-House
teaching—even if all one does is ask a few
questions about a few passages of Scripture.
Messianic Judaism, I believe, has unfairly
branded all who choose to speak or ask about the
subject with the moniker “Ephraimite,”
and immediately disregarding them.[3]
But then again, in my dealings with some of
today’s Messianic Jews, not only do they not
want to discuss the subject matter in any way,
a few of them want non-Jewish Believers to
pretty much vacate their Messianic Jewish
congregations.[4]
While they may claim that we are all equal in
Messiah Yeshua (Galatians 3:28; Colossians
3:11), experience has taught me that quite a few
Messianic Jews believe that they are closer to
God than people like myself, simply because of
their ethnicity. Some think that if you do not
interpret “all Israel will be saved” (Romans
11:26) as meaning that every single Jew who has
ever lived will come to Yeshua, that you are
anti-Semitic. Too frequently, Messianic Jews I
have interacted with do not consider me their
equal on a basic human level[5]—and
could by no means imagine that the restoration
of Israel only begins with the salvation
of Jewish people, not ending there. This is
by no means all Messianic Jews, but
Messianic Judaism does have some issues it is
presently wrestling with. All I can say for
myself is that much of Messianic Judaism needs
to be left in God’s hands right now, and they
need some space.
Those of us who think more is happening in the Messianic movement
also need some space. The time has come for a
Biblical Two-House teaching to emerge, one which
puts to rest the antics caused by the populism
of the last decade, and forces people to
actually engage with the Scriputral text and
think a little more clearly and reasonably. It
is fair to say that there will be some overlap
between some of the remarks made among the
Two-House populists, and what needs to be
examined. After all, I do believe just like they
that Israel is in the process of being restored,
and this does require me to recognize that a
“scattered Ephraim” will be gathered back into
the fold of Israel. Some of today’s Messianic
non-Jews may very well be proven—even if only by
the Lord when He returns—to have ancestry from
the “Lost Tribes” of Israel.
At the same time, though, to me this is an issue of eschatology and
is not at all to be an issue of spiritual
identity. My identity as a Believer is to be
focused around what Yeshua the Messiah has done
for me, in saving me from my sins and in making
me a new creation—“For
I determined to know nothing among you except
Yeshua the Messiah, and Him crucified” (1
Corinthians 2:2). As a consequence of my faith,
I do believe that I am a part of the
Commonwealth of Israel (Ephesians 2:11-12; 3:6)
or the Israel of God (Galatians 6:16), and that
what affects Israel—including Israel’s
prophesied restoration—will affect me in some
way. But what are some of the things that it
involves? This is why we have to identify the
passages of Scripture that deserve our
attention.
I would propose that our way to begin this review is in recognizing
four short points:
1.
Personal salvation in the Messiah of Israel, Yeshua (Jesus), is the
most important thing anyone of us can
possess. A person’s bloodline or pedigree
cannot guarantee someone eternal life.
People who are known to be of physical
Israel can still be eternally condemned
because of sin (Romans
3:9-11; cf. Psalm 14:1-3; 53:1-3).
2.
All people who have placed their trust in Messiah Yeshua today are
a part of the community of Israel. They are
“brought near” (Ephesians 2:13), just as
Ancient Israel was described to be a
community “that
has a god so near to it as is the
Lord
our God” (Deuteronomy 4:7; cf. Psalm 148:14;
Isaiah 56:3).
3.
All people within the Commonwealth of Israel are equal before the
Creator God and are to be treated as such
before one another. As indicated in
Galatians 3:28, this equality includes those
of Jewish and other nationalities, the
social statuses of bond and free, and the
genders of male and female.
4.
What is to occur regarding the Two Houses of Israel affects
one’s interpretation of prophecy. People
are still saved by the sacrifice of Yeshua
whether they are of the House of Judah, the
scattered House of Israel/Ephraim, or truly
of the nations. All who compose the
community of Israel via trust in Yeshua are
ultimately involved in Israel’s restoration.
Who is of Judah and Ephraim, specifically,
only concerns the completion of prophecy,
and some of those details may need to be
left to the Lord and sorted out in the
eschaton.
Some of what I have just listed above may sound a bit familiar for
those who have heard the populist Two-House
teaching. At the same time, some of the things
may sound a bit different. Faith in Yeshua,
for all people regardless of ethnicity, is
definitely placed as the most important thing.
The identity of who scattered Israel/Ephraim may
be is considered something left to prophecy, not
a person’s day-to-day identity in fulfilling the
call of God upon His people of making a positive
difference in the world. Some parts of this
proposed Two-House perspective are left in God’s
hands, as all people are a part of the
Commonwealth of Israel already via their
trust in Israel’s Messiah. Only He knows the
specific ancestry of those who might be
classified as “scattered Ephraim” in various
prophetic verses.
Developing a Biblical Two-House teaching, focused on the Scriptures
themselves and not the sensationalism of a slick
conference speaker, is not going to be easy at
the present time. Huge sectors of the Messianic
movement—Messianic Judaism, Messianic Two-House,
Messianic whatever—do not place that high a
value on detailed theology or exegesis. Too
many Messianics also lack patience. But if
there is a Biblical Two-House teaching to be
considered from the Scriptures, not only do the
relevant passages have to be identified and
classified; they also have to be examined in
much greater detail. This not only includes a
consideration for the surrounding text in which they
appear, but also must involve consultation with
the Hebrew and/or Greek source text, and an
array of technical commentaries that are Jewish,
Christian, conservative, and liberal.[6]
If we can do this, we might find that there
really is a Biblical basis for a Two-House
teaching, but we will also undoubtedly find
that certain voices among us have spoken without
thinking critically. But we have got to be
willing to commit the time and energy to do this,
and put things only using like Strong’s Concordance[7]
and unbalanced emotionalism off to the side.
The Biblical Passages that Deserve our Attention
Like many of you, I do not appreciate it that much when someone
tries to silence me and tell me that the
Two-House teaching—any Two-House teaching—is
non-Biblical. They think that because I am
non-Jewish and Messianic that I am trying to
find some lost “Ephraimite” ancestry. In
actuality, I really am not.[8]
I am, once again, still very much open to the
possibility that more is going on with
evangelical Christians entering into the
Messianic movement in considerable numbers,
beyond that of them being equal members of
Israel’s polity. But that is not what I am
really interested in as a teacher.
What I am more interested in is what the Bible has, or might, or
might not say about this issue. I think it is no
more illegitimate to ask the classic question, “Won't
you tell us what these actions of yours mean?”
(Ezekiel 37:18, NJPS) in Ezekiel joining the two
sticks of Judah and Ephraim together, than it is
to ask, How many people really participated in
the Exodus?” or even “What does yom
really mean in Genesis 1?” We are dealing with
the Bible here, and unless we want to just act
like certain passages do not appear in words we
think are inspired by the Creator God, we
have to deal with them in one way or another.
(And by the way, those other two questions will
have to be answered by our emerging Messianic
movement sometime also, as well.)
But how much of a case has really been made for a Biblical
Two-House teaching at present? How much work and
refinement might we really have to do in order
for our opinions to be legitimately considered
in the future?
I am about to give you an extensive list of Biblical passages (do
note that a few are from the deutero-canon),
eighty-one in total, that relate in some way to
the Biblical Two-House teaching I believe has to
emerge. (There are likely more references that
will need to be added in the future.) So you do
not get overwhelmed, I have split them up into
five sub-categories:
1.
Promises:
These passages relate to the promises of God
to multiply the descendants of Abraham,
Isaac, and Jacob, and how their seed was to
be a blessing to the entire world.
2.
History:
These passages concern the history of the
division of Ancient Israel into the Northern
and Southern Kingdoms, and their subsequent
dispersions by Assyria and Babylon as
detailed in the Biblical record.
3.
Prophecies:
These passages concern how all Israel is to
be redeemed within the course of God’s plan
of salvation history. Various prophecies
relating to the Two Houses of Israel need to
be evaluated to see if they have been
completed, partially completed, or are
awaiting full completion.
4.
Mission:
These passages detail what the mission of
Israel was intended to be by God. Was Israel
to be a nation chosen by Him, but only off
to itself? Or, is Israel to be active in
declaring to the world of His goodness,
mercy, and now redemption via the Messiah?
How does this affect what today’s Messianic
movement is to be, or become in the future?
Who is involved with the restoration of all
Israel: just ethnic Israel or all
humanity?
5.
Texts of Tension:
These are passages which today’s Two-House
sub-movement struggles with in one way or
another. What role is the Jewish theological
tradition to play in the future restoration
of Israel or Torah halachah? What are
a few of the subjects where advocates of the
populist Two-House teaching may have made
some overstatements?
I have summarized each of these Biblical references under these
sub-categories, along with a relevant question
or series of questions that we need to be asking
ourselves when we approach the text. It is my
hope that this list of passages—which absolutely
deserves our attention—will serve as a point of
reference for future exegetical papers
where the subject matter can be more fully
explored.
PROMISES
Genesis 12:1-3
“I Will Bless You”
How important is it for us to understand the
original promise that God made to Abraham,
about making him into a great nation that
was to be a blessing? How does this control
a significant part of the Biblical story,
and God’s steadily unfolding plan of
salvation history?
Genesis 17:1-9
God’s Covenant With Abraham
What are the specifics of God’s covenant made
by Abraham to multiply his descendants, and
make him a father of many nations? What is
the promise made by Him to give him a
special piece of land? Does this covenant
have continuing ramifications until today?
Genesis 17:20; 26:1-5
Abraham’s Covenant Confirmed With Isaac
How is God’s covenant with Isaac similar, or
different, from what He originally promised
Abraham? What are the similarities and
differences between what was promised to
Isaac, and what God says about Abraham’s
estranged son Ishmael?
Genesis 28:10-17
Abraham’s Covenant Confirmed with Jacob
How is God’s covenant with Jacob similar, or
different, from what He originally promised
Abraham? What might we need to consider
surrounding the circumstances of Jacob’s
dream?
Genesis 35:9-12
Jacob is Renamed Israel
What was the purpose in God renaming Jacob,
“Israel”? In what way does this speak to the
character of Jacob/Israel as a person? What
does this speak to those who follow after
him? What did God promise to Jacob after
renaming him?
Deuteronomy 1:10-11; 10:22
The Stars of the Sky
During the wilderness sojourn, Moses indicated
that Ancient Israel numbered as the stars of
Heaven. Is this an indication that God’s
promises of multiplicity to Abraham were
finished? Or, would there be some kind of an
ongoing fulfillment of this promise,
extending through Biblical history (1
Chronicles 27:23; Nehemiah 9:23)—and
possibly even to the present? How are
similar references to Israel being as “the
sand of the sea” (Genesis 32:12; 2 Samuel
17:11; 1 Kings 4:20; Hosea 1:10) to be
considered?
Galatians 3:6-9, 29
The Seed of Abraham
In his writing to the complex situation in
Galatia, what does Paul mean in asserting
that the non-Jewish Believers are the “seed”
of Abraham? Does this relate to only
spiritual seed, only physical seed, or is
this “seed” a multi-faceted dynamic with a
variety of components that have to be
weighted?
HISTORY
Joshua 11:21; Judges 10:9; 1 Samuel 17:52;
18:16; 2 Samuel 2:10; 3:10; 5:5; 11:11;
12:8; 19:11, 40ff; 20:2; 21:2; 24:1, 9; 1
Kings 1:35; 2:32; 4:20, 25
Two Houses of Israel Before the Divided
Kingdom?
In varied places throughout the Former
Prophets/Historical Books of the Tanach, we
see references to Judah and Israel/Ephraim,
prior to the division of the Israelite
Kingdom into the North and South. Are these
simply observations made by the historians
of the Southern Kingdom, who kept a record
of these histories? Are they the melding of
sources together from the so-called Elohist
(E) from the North, and Yahwist (J) from the
South, as espoused by the critical
tradition? Or, are they important clues that
even prior to the establishment of the
Israelite monarchy, there was a division
between Judah and Israel/Ephraim?
1 Kings 11:1-13, 26-43
The Kingdom of Israel Will Split
What are the spiritual circumstances which led
to the decline of King Solomon’s reign? How
did Solomon’s opulence and sin lead to
decree that Ancient Israel would be divided?
What did God communicate to Jeroboam about
how he would be given the ten northern
tribes?
1 Kings 12; 2 Chronicles 10:1-11:4
The Kingdom of Israel Splits
What were the political circumstances that
transpired after the death of King Solomon,
and the rise of King Rehoboam? How do we see
Jeroboam enter onto the scene, and the ten
northern tribes secede from the south? Why
is the Southern Kingdom prevented from
trying to retake the newly independent
Northern Kingdom? What does Jeroboam do to
solidify his power base?
2 Kings 17
The Northern Kingdom Falls to Assyria
Hoshea ascends to the throne as the last
monarch of the Northern Kingdom. As a result
of failing to pay tribute to Assyria, and
because of the great sin and idolatry of the
people, the Northern Kingdom of
Israel/Ephraim is defeated. Many are exiled
from their homes, with foreigners having
been brought in. How widespread was the
exile of the Northern Kingdom to Assyria?
How many people escaped to the Southern
Kingdom? How are we to consider statements
made by the author(s) of Kings, versus later
statements made by the Chronicler (2
Chronicles 5:26-27)?
2 Kings 24-25; 2 Chronicles 36:5-23
The Southern Kingdom Falls to Babylon
What are the complex series of circumstances
that befell the Southern Kingdom of Judah?
How were they engulfed by the rising
Babylonian Empire, and defeated because of
their great sin and rebellion against God?
How were the Jews taken into Babylonian
exile? How was God faithful to later restore
the Southern Kingdom exiles to their
homeland?
2 Chronicles 30:1-31:1
King Hezekiah’s Passover
King Hezekiah decrees that a grand Passover is
to be celebrated in the Southern Kingdom,
and feels it prudent to invite people from
the Northern Kingdom. Did this occur before
the fall of the Northern Kingdom, during the
Assyrian sieges, or right after?
Hosea 7
Why Will Ephraim be Punished by God?
What are some of the specific, significant
prophetic indictments against the Northern
Kingdom of Israel/Ephraim, for why it will
be punished by God? How is it important to
understand these decrees in the context of
history, but also how God always promises a
chance for restoration?
Ezra 2:70-3:1; 7:28; 8:25; 10:2; Nehemiah
1:6; 7:73; 9:1-2; et. al.
All Israel Everywhere, All Israel Present,
or What?
There is no denying the fact that when the
Southern Kingdom exiles returned from
Babylon, and began to start new lives, that
the people saw themselves as Israel. But are
post-exilic usages of “Israel” or “all
Israel,” tantamount to seeing “all Israel”
fully restored as is anticipated in the
prophecies of the Tanach? Or, is this a
recognition of how the Jewish exiles
continued to bear the torch of “Israel”?
How, in properly balancing the Biblical
data, do post-exilic usages of Israel seen
in Ezra-Nehemiah need to be approached?
1 Maccabees 12:1-23; 14:20-23
Statements About the Spartans
During the conflict between the Jewish
Maccabees and Greek Seleucids, the Jews seek
an alliance with the city of Sparta. In
their correspondence, it is claimed that the
Spartans are of the progeny of Abraham. What
does this reflect on who the Spartans
actually were, or at least what one Jewish
opinion was of their physical brethren
outside of Israel?
Luke 2:33-37; Tobit 1:3-4
Tribal Identity in the First Century
Is it commonly claimed that the Two Houses of
Israel have been reunited, because of the
fact that various people, who made up the
First Century Jewish community, could trace
their ancestry to some of the Northern
Tribes. Was this the case with a large
number of “Jews,” or only a handful of
people from the Northern Kingdom who
migrated to the Southern Kingdom?
John 7:28-36
Will Yeshua Go to the Greeks?
Yeshua is questioned about who He is, during
the celebration of the Feast of Tabernacles
in Jerusalem. In the questions asked of Him,
and specifically about where He intends to
go where people cannot find Him, the Lord is
asked whether He intends to go into the
Greek Dispersion. What does this mean? Is
this just speaking of the Hellenistic Jewish
community among the Greeks? Or is this
speaking of the Greeks themselves? If it is
the latter, how might it have reflected on
Jewish views of scattered Israel?
PROPHECY
Genesis 48-49
The Patriarch Jacob’s Last Words
Many readers of the Torah see important
prophecies delivered by Jacob in Egypt, as
he gathers his family together before his
death. What are the important destines of
Jacob’s descendants? How were the sons of
Jacob/Israel to multiply themselves? Did
Jacob foresee important events to befall
Israel in the future? If so, what are they,
and how do we need to make close
observations in the text, lest we make some
hasty conclusions?
Deuteronomy 4:23-40
Moses Issues Warnings of Dispersion
for Rebelling Against the Lord
Moses tells Ancient Israel that if they disobey
the Lord, or if their descendants disobey
the Lord and fall into idolatry, that they
will be scattered outside of the Promised
Land. Only during a time of distress will
Israel be able to fully seek out the Lord
and be properly restored.
Deuteronomy 30:1-14
Dispersed Israel Will Return to the Lord
A dispersed Israel, however far separated from
the Land of Israel, will be restored to the
Lord if they are truly repentant. Not only
will they be restored to a state of full
prosperity, but their enemies will find
themselves properly punished.
Isaiah 7-8
Immanuel Will Hearken a Time of Great Change
for Israel
The prophecy of the virgin conceiving and
giving birth is well known to anyone who
believes that Yeshua is the Messiah. But
what was the original scene and setting in
which Isaiah delivered this word to King
Ahaz? How did this involve an ancient
situation of the Southern Kingdom facing
doom, and a future situation of the
Messiah’s being born? How will Immanuel be a
stumbling block for both Judah and Israel?
Isaiah 11
The Shoot of Jesse Will Gather
the Dispersed of Israel and Judah
The prophecy of the shoot of Jesse coming forth
to righteously judge the world is rightly
applied to Yeshua the Messiah. But how often
is it overlooked that not only will Israel,
but Judah and Ephraim specifically, look to
Him in the Last Days? Not only will they
look to Him, but as they are regathered,
they will change the map of the Middle East
for Israel?
Isaiah 14:1-7
Israel’s Right to Taunt a Defeated Babylon
After regathering Israel, and with various
strangers joining themselves to Israel, the
Lord promises to give Israel rest. Israel
will also be allowed to taunt a fallen
Babylon. Is this prophecy something that has
been fulfilled in the past, or does it
relate to a future end-time conflict and
attendant Millennial Kingdom?
Isaiah 57:19; Ephesians 2:17
Peace and Healing Promised
A prophecy describing peace and healing is
quoted by Paul in his letter to non-Jewish
Believers in Asia Minor (Ephesians 2:17).
What is the wider context of this assertion
within Isaiah’s prophecies? What would its
usage in Ephesians specifically have
communicated to its audience?
Isaiah 66:7-24
The Rebirth of Israel Leads to the Return of
the Lord
Everyone in the Messianic community has heard
Isaiah’s prophecies, about a nation being
born in a day, applied to the creation of
the State of Israel in 1948. How many of us,
though, have often read only part of this
prophecy, and not the whole of the prophecy?
How will the rebirth of Israel lead to many
other important things, culminating in the
return of the Lord?
Jeremiah 3:6-25
Sinful Judah and Sinful Israel
Will Return to the Lord and to the Land
Both Judah and Israel are branded by the Lord
as though they are wives to be divorced.
Yet, even though both Judah and Israel have
proven themselves quite sinful, the Lord
calls them back to Himself. Restoration and
healing are promised to Judah and Israel, as
is a return to the Promised Land.
Jeremiah 16:10-21
Who Has Accepted “All Lies”?
The Prophet Jeremiah undoubtedly sees a time in
future history when there will be an Exodus
to the Promised Land of Israel, greater than
the Exodus from Egypt. Fishers and hunters
are going to be sent out to gather God’s
people. But are these fishers and hunters
sent out before or after the major Exodus?
Many Two-House advocates think that those
who have accepted “all lies” are today’s
Christians who acknowledge Jesus (Yeshua) as
their Savior. How is this view overstated,
not considering the time and setting of the
prophecy?
Jeremiah 23:1-8
The Righteous Branch Will Restore
Judah and Israel to the Their Own Soil
A righteous Branch, who Believers affirm is
Yeshua the Messiah, is going to rule in
justice and righteousness. Yet commonly
overlooked is how when He rules, both Judah
and Israel will dwell securely in their own
country. Promised with this is a future
Exodus greater than the Exodus from Ancient
Egypt.
Jeremiah 30
Israel and Judah Will Be Restored to Their
Previous Prosperity
The Lord promises to restore both Israel and
Judah to their homeland, and rebuild them as
they had once been. What does this prophecy
detail about not only such a regathering,
but also the punishment that had caused them
to be dispersed into the nations?
Jeremiah 31:1-20
God Will Regather and Restore a Previously
Faithless Ephraim
While it is easy to read through Jeremiah’s
prophecy and quickly apply it to the Jewish
people returning to the Land of Israel, a
fair reading shows that it mostly concerns
scattered Ephraim. How does this word set
both Judah and Israel up for the
inauguration of the New Covenant?
Jeremiah 31:31-34; Ezekiel 36:24-28
Romans 11:27; Hebrews 8:6-18; 10:15-18
What is the New Covenant?
Is the New Covenant something that is
completely separated from God’s Torah? Who
is the New Covenant to be made with: the
Christian Church, or a restored Israel of
Judah and Ephraim? In what way did the
Apostle Paul and the author of Hebrews
specifically appeal to the New Covenant
prophecies of the Tanach? What future
aspects of the New Covenant are yet to be
implemented?
Jeremiah 33
The Righteous Branch Will Fulfill God’s Word
to Israel and Judah
With the fall of Jerusalem imminent to the
Babylonians, Jeremiah prophesies a future
restoration of not only the House of Judah,
but also the House of Israel. A righteous
Branch will be used to execute justice on
the Earth, and God’s covenant with David
will be remembered.
Jeremiah 50-51
The Involvement of Israel and Judah in the
Final Fall of Babylon
Judah and Israel will join themselves together,
and return to their homeland weeping. Yet
this word is given within the context of the
fall of Babylon. Did not Babylon fall in
ancient times? Or, is there a
yet-to-be-expected final fall of Babylon?
How is the regathering of Israel to the
Promised Land connected to the fall of
Babylon? Does this necessitate Ancient
Babylon somehow being rebuilt in modern-day
Iraq? How many different opinions of this
prophecy need to be weighed into our
deliberations?
Ezekiel 20:27-41
Making Restored Israel Pass the Bar of
Judgment
After describing His deliverance of Ancient
Israel from Egypt, and His bringing them into
the Promised Land, the Lord was required to
punish the people for their disobedience. In
the future, Israel will be restored, but
just as there was a time of introspection in
the wilderness sojourn, so does it appear
that there is a future time of introspection
to be expected.
Ezekiel 37:15-28
Have the Two Sticks Been Reunited?
The two-stick prophecy, representing the Houses
of Judah and Ephraim, is probably the one
single text of Scripture that is referred to
the most when speaking of the restoration of
the Two Houses of Israel. Was this prophecy
fulfilled in ancient times, or does future
fulfillment await? What does this prophecy
teach us about the kind of unity that God
requires or expects among His people? Are there two, or three
groups, being brought together in this
prophetic oracle?
Ezekiel 36-39
The Wider Restoration of Israel
While the two-stick prophecy of Ezekiel 37 is
often given a great deal of attention by
today’s Two-House advocates, what role does
this play into the wider prophetic picture
delivered by Ezekiel? How was Israel
required to be punished? What does the
valley of the dry bones represent? What is
the conflict between Gog and Magog, and how
does it relate to the return of all Israel
to its homeland?
Daniel 9
The Seventy Weeks of Israel
The inauguration of the seventy weeks of Israel
prophecy is undoubtedly so the full
restoration of Israel can take place, and
everlasting righteousness can be brought to
the Earth. How do we carefully consider the
weight of this prophecy, given the multiple
interpretations of it present in
contemporary theology?
Hosea 1:10-11; 2:21-23
The Theme of Hosea’s Prophecies
It is unavoidable that the principal audience
of Hosea’s prophecies was the Northern
Kingdom of Israel/Ephraim. While the
Northern Kingdom was to be punished by God
for its sin, what are the main, overarching
themes of what Hosea communicates? How is
restoration promised for Israel and Judah in
the Last Days? How were some specific words
of Isaiah applied to the salvation of
non-Jewish Believers in the Apostolic
Scriptures?
Hosea 6:1-7
“He Will Raise Us Up”
What is intended by the ambiguous word, “He
will revive us after two days; He will raise
us up on the third day”? Is this intended to
be a future prophecy, describing a distant
restoration of Israel after 2,000 years? Or
is this intended to describe Israel’s
identification with the death, burial, and
resurrection of Messiah Yeshua?
Hosea 11
Ephraim Will Return Trembling from the West
In God’s punishing of Ephraim, people from the
Northern Kingdom will not be sent back to
Egypt, but rather to Assyria. God, however,
promises that He is in their midst, and that
at the appropriate time they will return to
their homeland from the West. How will this
prophecy be fulfilled in the future?
Zechariah 8
Judah as the Key to Israel’s Restoration
The Lord promises that although Judah and
Israel were a curse among the nations, that
they will be a blessing once again. Joy and
tranquility will be brought to Jerusalem.
Ten will grasp the hold of a Jew, because
God is there. How does this relate not only
to the end-times, but also to the
anticipated restoration of Israel?
Zechariah 9:11-17
A Past or Future Conflict With Greece?
The Prophet Zechariah speaks of a conflict that
occurs between Judah, Ephraim, and Greece.
Is this something that took place in past
history during the time of the Maccabees? Or
is this something to be anticipated in the
future, in a war with the regime of the
antimessiah? How does this prophecy fit into
the larger message and themes of Zechariah?
Zechariah 10
A Glad and Massive Restoration of Judah and
Joseph
Both Judah and Joseph will be saved and brought
back to their homeland by the Lord. In the
return from exile, the numbers are to be so
great that the surrounding territory will
not be able to hold all the returnees. What
are the implications of this prophetic word?
How frequently overlooked is this as
something that must take place before the
Messiah can return?
Zechariah 12
The Tents of Judah Will be Saved
There is undoubtedly a very special place in
the heart of God for the Jewish people. The
Prophet Zechariah speaks of how He will save
the tents of Judah, defending Jerusalem and
all those who come against it. The Jewish
people will have to look upon Yeshua, the
One whom they have pierced, in order to have
redemption on the day of great battle at
Megiddo.
Revelation 7:1-8
Who Are the 144,000?
The Book of Revelation records how 144,000
sealed servants of Israel will be sealed in
the Tribulation period? Who are these
people? Are they all Messianic Jews, or is
there something more that pre-millennial
interpreters might have missed? How do
various opinions need to be considered, and
unwarranted speculation put off to the side?
MISSION
Exodus 9:13-17
The God of the Whole Earth
The plagues that God dispenses upon Ancient
Egypt were not only for Pharaoh, the
Egyptians, or Israel—but for the whole
Earth. In what way does this affect how we
understand God acting on behalf of His
people in salvation history?
Exodus 12:37-38
A Mixed Multitude
Why were there other people who left with the
Ancient Israelites in the Exodus from Egypt?
Exodus 12:49; Leviticus 24:22; Numbers
15:15-16, 29
One Law for All
Does the Torah teach that its instructions
affect native-born Israel, as well as all
those who enter into God’s community? Or, is
the Torah to only be the possession of the
Jewish people today?
Exodus 19:5-6
A Kingdom of Priests
What does it mean for Israel to be called
out by God as a kingdom of priests? What
does being a priestly people actually mean
in terms of actually representing God to the
world?
Deuteronomy 4:4-9
“Your Wisdom in the Sight of the Peoples”
Today’s Messianic movement rightly emphasizes
that all Believers need to be connected, in
some way, to the foundational instruction of
God’s Torah. What does the Torah
specifically say about why its instruction
is to be kept? Are there any important,
missional aspects to obeying God’s
commandments that we too frequently
overlook?
Deuteronomy 7:6-8; cf. 26:17-19
A People for His Own Possession
What are the specific reasons, given by God, as
to why He chose Israel? How many significant
allusions are there in the Apostolic
Scriptures to Believers—regardless of their
ethnicity—similarly being people chosen for
Him?
Deuteronomy 32:8-9
Israel as the Boundary Markers for the Whole
Earth
What are the claims made about Israel serving
as boundary markers for the whole world? How
does this play into claims made by Paul in
Ephesians 1:5?
1 Kings 8:41-43; 2 Chronicles 6:32-33
Solomon Dedicates the Temple for What?
King Solomon’s prayer, dedicating the First
Temple, indicates a significant number of
reasons as how it is to function. One of the
most significant is so that outsiders hear
of Israel’s God and come to know Him.
Isaiah 2:3; Micah 4:2
“The Torah Will Go Forth From Zion”
There is an eschatological expectation that the
Torah will go forth from Zion, with the
nations streaming to hear it. How does this
affect the purpose and calling of today’s
Messianic movement, and the role it is to
play in the wider world?
Isaiah 19:19-25
“Egypt and Assyria—My People”
The Prophet Isaiah details a word from the Lord
where both Egypt and Assyria will be
considered His people. Considering this
expectation, how in the future eschaton will
distinct nationalities be preserved, even
though the Kingdom of God on Earth will be
considered to be the Kingdom of Israel?
Isaiah
42:5-7
Israel as a Light to the Nations
What is the role that Israel is to play in
serving God in the world? How is Israel to
be His light to the nations?
Isaiah 49:5-7
The Mission of the Messiah
As the Ultimate Servant, what are some of the
important things that the Messiah is to do?
How did Yeshua come as the light of Israel?
How is the salvation of Yeshua not only to
come to Israel, but also the whole world?
Isaiah 56:1-8
“The Foreigner Who Joins Himself”
In the Prophet Isaiah’s expectation of the
eschaton, foreigners are not allowed to call
themselves separate from the people of
Israel. They are also bidden to remember the
Sabbath, and are allowed to serve Him
faithfully.
Ezekiel 47:21-23
Millennial Israel Divided for the Tribes and
Sojourners
In the Millennial Kingdom, the Land of
Israel is not only divided up for the
returning tribes, but also for aliens who
are to be considered as those native-born.
What does this teach us about the
restoration of Israel, and how it is not at
all exclusive, but quite inclusive?
Amos 9:8-15; Acts 15:13-21
The Restoration of the Tabernacle of David
In the deliberations of the Jerusalem Council,
James the Just quotes from the Prophet Amos,
applying the prophecies of the restoration
of David’s Tabernacle to the salvation of
the nations. Why did he do this? What is the
purpose of the restoration of David’s
Tabernacle?
Matthew 16:18-19
On This Rock I Will (re)Build My Church
What did Yeshua really mean when He told Peter
the commonly quoted, “On this rock I will
build My church?” How easy it is for us to
overlook the Tanach intertextuality, where
the restoration of Israel is actually being
referred to?
Romans 9, 11
The Olive Tree of Israel
What was the purpose of the Apostle Paul
describing Israel as an olive tree? Who are
the nations that are grafted onto the tree,
and why are natural branches broken off?
What is the purpose of certain intertextual
references made from the Tanach (Hosea 2:23;
1:10; Isaiah 10:22-23), applied to the
salvation of non-Jews in the First Century?
What is the mystery regarding the
“fullness/full number of the Gentiles”? How
many ways does Paul use “Israel” in this
part of his letter? What did Paul want to
communicate to the mixed group of Believers
in Rome?
1 Corinthians 10:1-4
“Our Fathers Were All Under the Cloud
and Passed Through the Sea”
In referring to the Exodus and wilderness
sojourn to the Corinthians, did the Apostle
Paul really consider them to be just as
affected by it as his own Jewish brethren?
Did the largely non-Jewish Corinthians get
to participate as members of Israel, and
consider Israel’s Patriarchs their spiritual
forebearers too?
Galatians 6:16
The Israel of God
In the closing remarks of Paul’s letter to the
Galatians, he wishes peace upon the Israel
of God. Is this a reference to Jewish
Believers? Is it a reference to the Jewish
people? Or, is it a reference to the wider
community of God created by Messiah Yeshua?
Ephesians 2:11-13, 19-21; 3:6
The Commonwealth of Israel
What does Paul assert to the non-Jewish
Believers of Asia Minor in saying that they
were once separated from the Commonwealth of
Israel, but have now been brought near? What
does it mean that they are fellow heirs
along with the saints? Does it mean that via
trust in Israel’s Messiah, non-Jewish people
really do get to be a part of Israel? Is the
“commonwealth” of Israel actual citizenship,
or it is like being a part of a broad entity
like the British Commonwealth of Nations?
Ephesians 4:25
Functioning as Members of One Another
Writing to a group of prominently non-Jewish
Believers in Asia Minor, and asserting how
all people in the Body of Messiah are to be
united, why does Paul quote from Zechariah
8:16? How does this prophecy, speaking of
the nations approaching the Jewish people,
affect the current missiology of today’s
Messianic movement?
James 1:1
“Greetings to You of the Twelve Tribes”
To whom was the Epistle of James originally
written? Is it written to just Jewish
Believers in the First Century? Or is it
written to a wider audience, which James
actually recognized as being the “twelve
tribes” to some direct or indirect degree?
How must both Jewish and classical
parallels seen in James’ letter be
considered?
1 Peter 2:9-10
A Special, Redeemed People
In writing to a broad audience, including
non-Jewish Believers, the Apostle Peter
requires that their conduct be becoming of
God’s holiness. In instructing this of his
readers, he directly applies a whole host of
Tanach passages that detail not only
Israel’s calling, but also Israel’s
restoration (Deuteronomy
7:6; 10:15; Exodus 19:6; Isaiah 61:6; 43:21;
Deuteronomy 4:20; 14:2; Hosea 2:23).
TEXTS OF TENSION
Genesis 45:1-10
Joseph Reveals Himself to His Brothers
Many Two-House advocates believe that the
revealing of scattered Israel/Ephraim will
take place in a similar way that Joseph in
Egypt revealed himself to his brothers. If
this is something to be considered, are
there any serious points that may need to be
learned from the Joseph story that are being
presently overlooked?
Genesis 49:9-10
“The Scepter Will Not Depart from Judah”
What does the Patriarch Jacob mean in claiming
that the scepter of leadership will not
depart from Judah? Was it to only be true
until the Messiah arrived, or does it still
continue in some way? What implications are
there for a restored Israel having a Jewish
leadership, or at least some kind of Jewish
lead in its Torah halachah?
Deuteronomy 4:1-2; 12:32
“As It is Written...”
Many Two-House advocates today believe that it
is inappropriate to consider the Rabbinical
tradition in our application of the Torah.
They insist that the Pentateuch teaches that
only the Written Torah, and not any of the
Oral Torah, is to be consulted. Is this
really what the Torah says? How is the
command not to add to God’s instruction be
counterbalanced with assertions made later
in the same book?
Matthew 10:5-6; 15:21-28; Mark 7:24-30
“Only to the Lost Sheep of the House of
Israel”
Various Two-House advocates have claimed that
the salvation available in Yeshua is only
available for physical Israelites. Is this
true from an honest reading of the Gospels?
How does Yeshua’s interaction with the
Canaanite/Syrophoencian woman show this to
be a gross overstatement—and how the
Messiah’s salvation is intended for all?
Matthew 23:2-3
Who Sits in the Seat of Moses?
Did Yeshua the Messiah intend for His followers
to follow the halachic lead of the
Pharisees, and by extension, observe many of
the mainline customs of Judaism today? Or,
did Yeshua only intend for His followers to
follow the Written Torah, without any
outside tradition to ever consult or
consider? What is the controversy regarding
the so-called Hebrew Gospel of Matthew, that
has become so affluent and influential in
various Two-House quarters in recent days?
Luke 15:11-32
“My Son Returns Home”
Many Two-House advocates believe that
Yeshua’s parable of the prodigal son speaks
exclusively about the return of scattered
Israel/Ephraim back home, with a jealous
brother Judah. Is this really what the
parable of the prodigal son speaks about?
How important is it to examine, in closer
detail, what the parable of the prodigal son
communicates to people of faith desiring
reconciliation with God? What principles can
be derived from this in approaching the
prophesied restoration of Israel?
Romans 3:1-2
Who Has the Oracles of God?
What does the Apostle Paul mean when he asserts
that the Jewish people have been entrusted
with the “oracles” of God? What are the
oracles of God, specifically? It is just the
Written Torah, or also oral explanations of
how the Torah is to be followed? What does
it mean to show the Jewish people and the
Jewish Synagogue proper respect, in
recognizing that these “oracles” have been
preserved by them?
Romans 3:9-18
All Are Subject to Sin
Are the Jewish people so special to God that He
will never condemn any of them on Judgment
Day? Why are the Apostle Paul’s words about
all human beings being subject to sin, so
widely ignored in today’s Messianic
movement? Why do we not take seriously not
only his conclusions, but the considerable
amount of Tanach support he provides for it?
Galatians 3:28
Biblical Equality and Today’s Messianic
Movement*
How significant and subversive was the Apostle
Paul’s claim that all people—regardless of
ethnicity, social status, or gender—are
equal, for a First Century society? Is it
possible that in the quest for many
non-Jewish Messianic Believers, to be
recognized as the equals of Jewish
Believers, that something has been missing?
Colossians 3:11
The Renewal That Knows No Boundaries
How often do we overlook how broad-sweeping the
power of the gospel is in changing people?
In the Apostle Paul’s letter to the
Colossians, how did the various groups
mentioned all regard the other as inferior?
How are these prejudices not only to be removed
in Messiah, but how are we to function as
redeemed people in Him?
1 Timothy 1:3-7
A Warning About Genealogies and Torah Abuse
What is the specific warning by Paul to Timothy
in not being concerned about genealogies?
Does this have any application today, with
various Two-House teachers trying to trace
the paths of the “Lost Tribes,” adhering to
various pseudo-histories? How do people
easily get off of the mark of the Scriptures
themselves?
Zechariah 4; Revelation 11:1-12
Who Are the Two Witnesses?
It is commonly asserted among some Two-House
advocates that the two witnesses of the Book
of Revelation are actually the Two Houses of
Israel, and not two specific people. Is this
a fair assumption to make, or is this an
overstatement that is made? How must the
evidence, including a wide array of
interpretations for Revelation, be
considered?
Moving Forward With the Required Refinement
After looking through these eighty-one different references, it is
probably safe for me to say that you may be
overwhelmed with information. Some of you, who
have believed in some form of the Two-House
teaching, may have never seen all, or at least
most, of the relevant Biblical passages laid out
and classified like this before. Likewise, some
of you who may have been critical of the
Two-House teaching, perhaps even claiming that
it is non-Biblical, have now seen some Biblical
passages that you will have to engage with on
some level and can no longer ignore. More than
anything else, those of us who believe in the
basic message of the Two Houses of Israel coming
together have some major work ahead of us.
Because of the antics and sensationalism that we witnessed in the
2000s, more than a few people in Messianic
Judaism and the One Law sub-movement would just
prefer to stay away from any and/or all of the
information that relates to the Two-House
teaching. While I share some of their pessimism,
I think that any honest reading of the Holy
Scriptures makes completely ignoring the subject
to be unreasonable. We very much have to read
each of these passages in much closer detail,
recognizing that the restoration of all Israel
goes beyond the salvation of the Jewish people
and a Jewish return to the Holy Land. While
these are two very important things, and I by
all means rejoice over them, more is to be
anticipated.
A return of people descended from the Northern Kingdom of
Israel/Ephraim is spoken of in the Bible. Yet it may
very well turn out, that in the end, a person
like me in the flesh is a complete and total
Gentile with no physical connection to the
Patriarchs of Israel. Even if that is true,
God’s Word will still take its course and
prophecy will be fulfilled. And via my faith in
Israel’s Messiah, I am still very much an equal
part of Israel like anyone physically descended
from the Patriarchs! Other people get to be
involved in Israel’s restoration outside that of
Judah and Ephraim.
There is a strong need to move away from the wishes of those who
would prefer to make the Two-House teaching
more simplistic for people to grasp—as
though it can be explained on the back of a
business card—and for that matter any impetus to
make any aspect of Messianic theology more
simplistic. On the contrary, the time has come
for the Two-House teaching to become more
Biblical, and for our overall theology to become
more multi-faceted and engaged. The Two-House
teaching is desperately overdue for a revamp in
the 2010s, and in putting some of the things
advocates propose to the touchstone of the
Scriptures. The emphasis needs to return to the
Biblical text itself, veering away from the
extremes, and a season is coming where we need
to be more self-critical than we have ever been
before.
In submitting to this refining process, we will see an appropriate
Biblical Two-House teaching emerge to properly
counter the extremism of the populist Two-House
teaching. This will be something that is very
streamlined, and we may find that some of us may
have to tone down a Two-House emphasis that we
have made from various Biblical passages where
it is simply not to be found. Likewise, we
definitely have a need to play up the missional
aspects of what Israel is required by God to be,
and how Israel is to be a blessing to the entire
world. Any and all speculation about where this
tribe or that tribe went needs to be stopped,
because the Apostles themselves, while applying
prophecies of Israel’s restoration to the
salvation of the nations (i.e., Romans 9:25-28;
1 Peter 2:9-10), never labeled any non-Jew as
being of “Tribe XYZ.” And, should critics to a
Biblical Two-House teaching arise, when
criticized we will simply take the above list
and politely ask them to provide their own
interpretations of the same passages. They are
certainly free to disagree, but they are not
free to disagree and then ignore the relevant
verses.
For the future, to dispel the idea that the restoration of all
Israel is exclusively about Judah and
Ephraim coming together, what we need to
focus upon more is all Believers being a part
of the community of Israel (Galatians 6:16;
Ephesians 2:11-13; 3:6). This is an assembly of
faithful which is destined for its members to
play a role in the restoration of God’s Kingdom
on Earth. What we call the reunion of the Two
Houses of Israel, happens to be a massively
overlooked part of that restoration, but it does
include more people than just Judah or Ephraim.
This list of Biblical passages that I have compiled does need to be
something that we begin to pay attention to. It
is high time that we look at them in greater
detail, and consider what other people—trusted
scholars, Rabbis, and theologians—have said
about them. Would you not like to know what
people in today’s Synagogue or Church think
about these parts of the Bible? I know I do.
We might find people agreeing with us, and
people disagreeing with us. While ideally there
should be a complete Messianic commentary
written on every book of the Bible, and special
attention given within those commentaries to
these passages, the time and effort required to
accomplish may take too long considering how
expedient it is to see the Two-House teaching
refined. While writing commentaries should by no
means go by the wayside, most of the above
passages will instead need to be addressed in
the form of exegetical papers that can be
included in future commentaries.
I believe that if we look at all of the references compiled, it
will be very difficult for people to just
casually discount any Two-House teaching as
being “non-Biblical.” Sure, there have been
antics and sensationalism and some bad things
that have become associated with the Two-House
sub-movement. I have steadily spoke against
these things.[9]
At the same time, though, each of us has to
deal with the Biblical text. We each have a
serious responsibility to provide our own
interpretations, thoughts, and opinions for what
the Bible says about this subject matter—and how
the restoration of Israel is to come about.
If we consider the fact that each one of the references above
represents a paper to be written, with the
average length being 10-15 pages (and being able
to be integrated into future commentaries),
we really do have a long way to go. We will
by no means have all of the answers tomorrow,
and it could actually take ten years or more for
each of these passages to be carefully examined.
More passages are likely to be added to the list
over time. I would respectfully ask critics of
the Two-House teaching to give us some time and
space to accomplish the necessary work—not only
in refining what this phenomenon is, Biblically,
but in being able to implement our conclusions
in teaching and instructing people.
Ironically, for a Bible teacher like myself, whose view of the
Two-House teaching is different in many places
than Two-House populists who make it the very
center of their spiritual identity—I may
actually find myself writing much, much more
about this issue than them. For someone who is
actually more concerned about us properly
understanding the Apostle Paul and the Torah,
the Messiahship of Yeshua, and the reliability
of the Scriptures, I could actually—because I am
teaching on the Scriptures—address the Two-House
teaching in much greater detail and breadth,
than those who have entire ministries focused
around this one single issue. This is something
interesting to contemplate! Let the work
begin...
J.K. McKee (B.A., University of Oklahoma; M.A., Asbury
Theological Seminary) is the editor of TNN Online (www.tnnonline.net)
and is a Messianic apologist. He is author of several books,
including: The New Testament Validates Torah, Torah In the
Balance, Volume I, and When Will the Messiah Return?.
He has also written many articles on the Two Houses of Israel
and Biblical theology, and is presently focusing on Messianic
commentaries on various books of the Bible.
NOTES
[1]
I will confess that I once fell into
thinking that if a non-Jewish Believer
were attracted to the Messianic
movement, this was an automatic
indication that he or she was most
probably a lost Israelite (or even an “Ephraimite”).
But only God knows the true pedigree
of any person. Over time, in editing
previous articles and materials I have
written, I have tried to make them
reflect a more “hands off” view in
determining the specificity of who
scattered Israel/Ephraim may be—very
much leaving the details to be
determined by Him in the eschaton. I
would simply affirm that a scattered
Israel/Ephraim is “out there,” and that
more is indeed going on in today’s
Messianic movement than Messianic Jewish
leaders are willing to admit, who deny
any kind of Two-House regathering.
Yet even though I may
have overstated things in the past, I am
also keen to note that I never passed
on the teachings and conclusions of
pseudo-historians like Yair Davidy or
Steven Collins. I find their teachings
and conclusions, at best, to be
interesting works of extrapolated
fiction, without any real exegetical or
Biblical bearing on what is happening in
the Messianic movement.
[2]
Please note that as an
egalitarian, I have no problem with
qualified women being in positions of
teaching or leadership. I do have a
problem, though, with unqualified
people—female or male—being in
positions of teaching or leadership.
Consult the FAQ on the
TNN website “Women
in Ministry.”
[3]
I have
witnessed many examples of this over the
past ten years, with not enough
fair-minded dialogue. Perhaps this has
only been my experience, and there are
some Messianic Jews interested in
honestly examining what the Holy
Scriptures say.
[4]
For a summary of this,
consult the blog entry by Stuart
Dauermann, “Messianic Jewish
Congregations and Disappointed Gentiles
Friends,” posted 17 March, 2009,
available for access at <http://www.mjti.com/index.php?option=com_myblog&show=Messianic-Jewish-Congregations-and-Disappointed-Gentile-Friends.html&Itemid=221>.
Of course, one notable
issue, that is not even discussed, is
that if non-Jewish Believers make up a
majority of Messianic Jewish
congregations, they presumably also make
up a majority of the tithes and
offerings. How would these monies be
quickly replaced if such people were
pressured into leaving? Could not a
significant base of revenue be lost for
Messianic Judaism?
[5]
Simply ask yourself the
last time you really heard a fair-minded
Messianic Jewish teaching on Romans chs.
1-3, where the Apostle Paul identifies
sin as a common human problem,
and he specifically refutes the idea
that Jewish possession of the Torah in
the First Century would curry any
special favors on Judgment Day.
[6]
An excellent listing of
references we can be considering is seen
in David R. Bauer, An Annotated Guide
to Biblical Resources for Ministry
(Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2003).
[7]
Consult the editor’s
article “Getting
Beyond Strong’s Concordance.”
[8]
Unlike many Two-House
advocates or adherents who visit the
Land of Israel, I did not necessarily
feel like I had “come home” when I went
on a tour of Israel in 2004. Quite to
the contrary, I felt that Israel was a
place where there was an extreme amount
of spiritual tension, and I did not even
feel that welcome as a guest
until about half-way through my tour.
(This could very well, however, have
been the result of the impending death
of Yasser Arafat in November 2004, which
took place in conjunction with my
visit.)
[9]
Consult the editor’s
articles “The
Quest for Credibility”
and “The
Top Ten Urban Myths of Today’s Messianic
Movement.”
|